Uploaded image for project: 'DRP 2-D Pipeline'
  1. DRP 2-D Pipeline
  2. PIPE2D-1612

b2 reports significantly more CRs than other detectors

    XMLWordPrintable

    Details

    • Type: Task
    • Status: Open (View Workflow)
    • Priority: Normal
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • Affects Version/s: None
    • Fix Version/s: None
    • Component/s: None
    • Labels:

      Description

      In doing some work for PIPE2D-1609, I noticed in the processing logs that b2 was finding significantly more CRs, by an order of magnitude:

      (arm: 'b', spectrograph: 4, visit_group: 115842) - Found 717 cosmic rays (4207 pixels)
      (arm: 'b', spectrograph: 4, visit_group: 115842) - Found 760 cosmic rays (3717 pixels)
      (arm: 'r', spectrograph: 3, visit_group: 115842) - Found 538 cosmic rays (5989 pixels)
      (arm: 'b', spectrograph: 2, visit_group: 115842) - Found 7476 cosmic rays (22295 pixels)
      (arm: 'r', spectrograph: 3, visit_group: 115842) - Found 654 cosmic rays (6274 pixels)
      (arm: 'b', spectrograph: 2, visit_group: 115842) - Found 7564 cosmic rays (21694 pixels)
      (arm: 'r', spectrograph: 2, visit_group: 115842) - Found 582 cosmic rays (6638 pixels)
      (arm: 'b', spectrograph: 3, visit_group: 115842) - Found 623 cosmic rays (4588 pixels)
      (arm: 'b', spectrograph: 4, visit_group: 115842) - Found 0 overlapping cosmic ray pixels
      (arm: 'r', spectrograph: 4, visit_group: 115842) - Found 499 cosmic rays (5647 pixels)
      (arm: 'r', spectrograph: 3, visit_group: 115842) - Found 531 cosmic rays (5511 pixels)
      (arm: 'b', spectrograph: 2, visit_group: 115842) - Found 7435 cosmic rays (22040 pixels)
      (arm: 'r', spectrograph: 2, visit_group: 115842) - Found 585 cosmic rays (6812 pixels)
      (arm: 'r', spectrograph: 4, visit_group: 115842) - Found 664 cosmic rays (6475 pixels)
      (arm: 'b', spectrograph: 3, visit_group: 115842) - Found 520 cosmic rays (3471 pixels)
      (arm: 'r', spectrograph: 2, visit_group: 115842) - Found 712 cosmic rays (7088 pixels)
      (arm: 'r', spectrograph: 4, visit_group: 115842) - Found 550 cosmic rays (5557 pixels)
      (arm: 'b', spectrograph: 3, visit_group: 115842) - Found 539 cosmic rays (2820 pixels)
      (arm: 'r', spectrograph: 3, visit_group: 115842) - Found 0 overlapping cosmic ray pixels
      (arm: 'b', spectrograph: 2, visit_group: 115842) - Found 5139 overlapping cosmic ray pixels
      (arm: 'b', spectrograph: 3, visit_group: 115842) - Found 0 overlapping cosmic ray pixels
      (arm: 'r', spectrograph: 4, visit_group: 115842) - Found 0 overlapping cosmic ray pixels
      (arm: 'r', spectrograph: 2, visit_group: 115842) - Found 0 overlapping cosmic ray pixels

      The visit_group is 115842 and has visits 115842, 115843, 115844. Zooming in on a random section of each of those visits shows masks for CRs where there does not appear to be an actual CR in any of the three visits.

      I additionally processed trace=115957, 115958 and neon=115830, 115831, 115832. The second set of trace values also show a magnitude higher order for b2. The neon arcs don't seem to be out of line with the other detectors but I still need to investigate a bit more.

      FYI, I'm working on the tools to make CR QA reporting easier.

        Attachments

        1. Figure 1 (4).png
          Figure 1 (4).png
          109 kB
        2. Figure 1 (5).png
          Figure 1 (5).png
          92 kB
        3. Figure 1 (6).png
          Figure 1 (6).png
          110 kB
        4. Figure 1 (7).png
          Figure 1 (7).png
          109 kB

          Activity

            People

            • Assignee:
              Unassigned
              Reporter:
              wtgee Wilfred Gee
            • Votes:
              0 Vote for this issue
              Watchers:
              1 Start watching this issue

              Dates

              • Created:
                Updated: