Subaru FITS committee looked at a sample PFSB file (PFJB02548123.fits). There are comments as follows. Comments provided in INSTRM-1444 are also applicable.

Misssing common keywords

• BIN-FCT[1-2]
• BLANK
• BUNIT
• DETECTOR
• DET-TMP
• EXP-ID
• FRAMEID
• GAIN

Missing Spectroscopy/Spectroscopy keywords

Note: listed for completeness - Subaru rule is being updated for MOS/fibre mode.

• DISAXIS
• DISPERSR
• SLIT
• SLITCPIX[1 -2]
• SLIT-LEN
• SLIT-PA
• SLIT-WID
• WAVELEN
• WAVE-MAX
• WAVE-MIN

Issues

Note: most of them have already discussed during the discussion on PFSA files.

• WCS to be defined
• default values for instrument & origin keywords such as TELESCOP, OBSERVAT, OBS-MOD to be checked
• There are no time/temporal keywords in extension images. Is this acceptable?
• EXPTIME exists only in primary HDU and no info for extension images. Is this acceptable? Comment is required. (EXPTIME=W_H4NRED*W_FRMTIM ?)
• This file is not compressed. Is this a plan or will compression be enabled?
• It is not clear what is in the 1st and 2nd extension, respectively (not exactly the FITS issue, though).
• Do we plan to inclde additional HDUs per discussion on JIRA?
  1. RESET HDU for IRP files? (INSTRM-1336) plus a keyword for indicating the file storing/reading (e.g., IRP or not) mode?
  2. "at the end (summary) HDU" (DAMD-7) e.g., there is no direct info for NDR etc.
  seems to be without IRP so we have no REF HDUs, correct?
• Formatting for float values should be checked.

Undefined basic keyword

• RA_CMD, DEC_CMD --> _These will be added to the Subaru's FITS dictionary if it's necessary to include them in the header of PFS data._

other minor comments

• MJD-STR = 59497.6215458 / [d] MJD at exposure start --> _%20.8f, but I guess it's provided by Gen2, and shorter length is okay if it's sufficient_
• EXPTIME = 3257.115 --> _comment needed (it's defined as %20.2f, but seems to need this presision in [s]?)_